AMP vs MATHia

MATHia follows each step of a student's work, and the blended algebra course its evidence comes from has a large independent randomized trial behind it1,5. It is sold to schools for grades 6 to 12 and works beside a teacher who decides what comes next1,2. AMP is open to any family, runs from counting to precalculus, and makes those choices itself at every answer.

Try it free

Why AMP

A family can buy AMP today

Carnegie Learning publishes no price for MATHia, and its MATHia pages ask schools to contact the company1,2. We found no family or homeschool plan on its pages1,2,3. AMP is sold to families, tutors and schools alike, and the first 100 answers and 5 workbooks are free, with no card.

One program from counting to precalculus

MATHia covers grades 6 to 12 and ends at Algebra II and Integrated Math III; we found no precalculus course on its pages2. Younger students need a different product, the game-based MATHia Adventure3. AMP runs from counting through precalculus on one map of 336 skills, so a learner who is far ahead, or behind in one part of math, never has to change programs.

The research: Practice at the learner’s level

AMP makes the calls a MATHia teacher makes

Carnegie Learning built MATHia to work alongside core instruction, and the teacher decides what comes next1. In the version tested at scale, classes spent three days a week with a teacher and two on the software7. AMP places the learner within the first 24 problems, keeps a level in each of 14 strands, chooses every problem after that, and sends practice back to what a skill builds on after two misses in a row. Every problem type has a hint and a written lesson with a worked example, so no adult has to teach first.

The research: Practice at the learner’s level · The research: Mastery, and repair of gaps · The research: Lessons with worked examples

Learned skills come back on a schedule

In the studied version, students advanced through the software as they mastered skills7. We found no scheduled review of mastered skills on its MATHia pages1,2. AMP brings each learned skill back after 6 hours, 1 day, 3 days, 1 week, 2 weeks and a month, mixed with other topics, and a miss resets the schedule. In a randomized trial with 787 seventh graders, mixed and spaced practice scored 62% on a test a month later, against 38% for practice in blocks11.

The research: Spaced, mixed review

Paper made for each learner

MATHia is software. In the blended course, paper comes as student textbooks and worksheets7, and we found no printable work made for the individual student. AMP prints unlimited workbooks composed from the learner's own record, each with a worked answer key, and results entered from paper count toward the learner's level.

Side by side

AMPMATHia
Price$599 a year or $59 a month for the first child, then $399 or $39 for each more. Two parents practice free. Full refund within 30 days.Not published. Its MATHia pages ask schools to contact the company1,2.
Who can buyFamilies, tutors and schools, directly. Free to start without a card: 100 answers and 5 workbooks. Arizona ESA, Arkansas EFA and New Hampshire EFA funds pay for it.Schools and districts. We found no family or homeschool plan1,2,3.
RangeCounting through precalculus in one program: 336 skills on one map.MATHia: grades 6 to 12, through Algebra II and Integrated Math III2. Kindergarten to grade 5 is a separate game-based product, MATHia Adventure3.
Finding the starting pointNo separate test. Placement takes the first 24 problems of practice. After that, every answer adjusts a level in each of 14 strands of math.No placement test described on its MATHia pages. The teacher assigns the work1.
TeachingA one-step hint and a written lesson with a worked example for every problem type. Worked steps after every answer. Narrated lesson films.Problem solving with hints that respond to the student's strategy, checked step by step1. In blended courses a teacher and textbook carry the lessons7.
What decides the next problemAMP chooses every problem from the learner’s answers: new work just within reach, a prerequisite, or review.Practice on skills not yet mastered, inside the work the teacher assigns. The teacher decides what comes next1.
MasteryFour of the last five answers right without help. An answer after a hint doesn’t count. Two misses in a row send practice back to what the skill builds on.Progress by mastery, skill by skill, shown on a Skillometer1,7. We found no published mastery rule.
ReviewScheduled. Learned skills come back after six hours, a day, three days, a week, two weeks and a month, mixed with other topics.No scheduled review of mastered skills found on its MATHia pages1,2.
PrintUnlimited workbooks made for each learner, each with a worked answer key. Results entered from paper count.Student textbooks and worksheets in the blended course7. No printable work made for the individual student found.
What the adult has to doNothing to plan, teach or grade. AMP places the learner, chooses each problem, checks it and schedules review.A teacher assigns the work, watches LiveLab to see who is working or idle, and decides what comes next1,2.
ReportsThe level in every strand with its likely range, skills, time, and the actual problems behind each number. For teachers, who needs them today.For teachers: LiveLab, Data Insights, the Skillometer, skill-by-skill progress toward mastery and projected outcomes1,2.
EvidenceA published rationale (ESSA Tier 4) with the research behind each part, public source code, and outcome studies from 2027, each registered before it starts.Blended Algebra I course: randomized trial, none in year one, about 0.2 SD in year two in high schools5. MATHia alone: unrated by Evidence for ESSA9.

What MATHia is

From Carnegie Learning

MATHia comes from Carnegie Learning, a Pittsburgh company1. It is tutoring software for grades 6 to 12, from middle-school math through Algebra I, Geometry, Algebra II and Integrated Math I to III2. Carnegie Learning sells it to schools as a supplement that works alongside core instruction1. A separate product, MATHia Adventure, offers game-based practice for kindergarten to grade 53.

A student works through workspaces of real problems. MATHia responds to each step of the student's reasoning, not only the final answer, and its hints respond to the student's strategy1. Practice targets the skills the student has not yet mastered, and a Skillometer shows progress. The teacher assigns the work, watches LiveLab to see who is working and who is idle, and decides what comes next1,2.

MATHia's research comes from Cognitive Tutor, Carnegie Learning's earlier blended algebra course. In the version studied at scale, classes spent three days a week with a teacher and textbook and two days on the software7. Carnegie Learning still sells blended courses that pair MATHia with a curriculum10. This page compares the software.

What MATHia does well

The evidence

MATHia

MATHia's strongest evidence comes from Cognitive Tutor Algebra I, Carnegie Learning's earlier blended course. RAND researchers matched schools into pairs in seven states, randomly assigned one school in each pair to the course, and followed them for two years; the cost analysis of the trial was sponsored by the U.S. Institute of Education Sciences5,7,8. In high schools alone the trial covered 73 schools in 51 districts and more than 11,000 students7. Classes spent three days a week with a teacher and two on the software, against the schools' usual textbooks, and took an algebra exam7. There was no effect in the first year. In the second year high schools gained about 0.2 standard deviations, about 8 percentile points for the median student5,6. The middle-school estimate was similar in size but not significant6.

The What Works Clearinghouse, using its own calculations, found no significant effect in year one and a year-two gain that lost significance after adjusting for multiple comparisons7. It also noted that students enrolled several months after schools were assigned, which weakens the randomization. Its 2016 report on Cognitive Tutor Algebra I covered five studies with algebra findings, with an average gain of 4 percentile points and a range from -7 to +19. For Cognitive Tutor Geometry, one randomized study of 669 students, it found potentially negative effects, -8 points7.

Evidence for ESSA rates Carnegie Learning's High School Math Solution Algebra I, which pairs MATHia with the curriculum, Strong: three Cognitive Tutor Algebra I studies, average effect size +0.0410. It lists MATHia on its own without a rating: "Qualifying studies found no significant positive outcomes"9. Carnegie Learning's research page says standalone MATHia meets ESSA Tier 24.

Carnegie Learning's research page says the blended course "nearly doubled growth" in year two, which is the second-year result of the same trial4. It also cites EMERALDS, in which students who completed more MATHia workspaces in middle school did better in Algebra I1,4. That compares heavier users with lighter ones, and students who use a program most differ from the rest before they start. The MATHia Adventure page cites no outcome study3.

AMP

MATHia moves a student on as skills are mastered7. AMP adds two things the research supports. Mixed, spaced review: in a randomized trial of 787 seventh graders that meets What Works Clearinghouse standards without reservations, students whose practice mixed and spaced earlier topics scored 62% on a test a month later, against 38% for practice in blocks; the test was the researchers' own11. Worked examples: across 55 studies in math they improved performance with an average effect of g = 0.4812, and every AMP problem type has one. We expect a program that does both at every problem, and that any family can use, to show it in outcomes. That is our bet, and we have committed to testing it in public.

AMP is new, and its own outcome studies have not run yet. They begin in 2027: growth on a national test against hours of use, then comparison groups, then randomized trials. Each will be registered before it starts and published whatever it finds. Until then, the research behind each part of AMP is laid out in our report, and the code is public.

The research behind AMP

Choose MATHia if

Choose AMP if

Questions

Can parents or homeschoolers buy MATHia?

We found no family or homeschool plan. Carnegie Learning's MATHia pages publish no price and ask schools to contact the company1,2. AMP sells to families directly, at $599 a year or $59 a month for the first child, and the first 100 answers are free.

Is MATHia proven to work?

Its blended Cognitive Tutor Algebra I course showed no effect in the first year of a large randomized trial and about 0.2 standard deviations in the second, in high schools5. Evidence for ESSA rates the blended High School Math Solution Algebra I Strong and lists MATHia on its own without a rating10,9.

Does AMP check each step the way MATHia does?

Not in the same way. MATHia responds to each step of a student's reasoning as they work1. AMP checks the final answer exactly, checks typed lines of work on 64 problem types, and shows the full worked steps after every answer.

My child uses MATHia at school. Can we use AMP at home?

Yes. AMP is a separate program. It places the learner within the first 24 problems and keeps a level in each strand of math, and it covers the grades before and after MATHia's as well.

Sources

  1. MATHia (Carnegie Learning)
  2. MATHia demo and samples (Carnegie Learning)
  3. MATHia Adventure (Carnegie Learning)
  4. Research (Carnegie Learning)
  5. Pane, Griffin, McCaffrey & Karam (2014), Effectiveness of Cognitive Tutor Algebra I at scale, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 36(2)
  6. RAND research brief RB-9746 on the Cognitive Tutor Algebra I trial
  7. What Works Clearinghouse (2016), Cognitive Tutor intervention report
  8. RAND technical report TR-1171-1, cost analysis of the Cognitive Tutor Algebra I trial
  9. MATHia (Evidence for ESSA)
  10. Carnegie Learning High School Math Solution Algebra I (Evidence for ESSA)
  11. Rohrer, Dedrick, Hartwig & Cheung (2020), A randomized controlled trial of interleaved mathematics practice (What Works Clearinghouse review)
  12. Barbieri et al. (2023), A meta-analysis of the worked examples effect on mathematics performance

Checked November 2026.

MATHia is a trademark of its owner. AMP is not affiliated with it. Found an error? Write to skylar@corpora.inc.

More comparisons

All comparisons · AMP · Research