AMP vs ST Math

ST Math has what few math programs have: an independent randomized trial, with a small effect, and a Strong rating from Evidence for ESSA2,14. Its visual puzzles start in PreK, and a family pays $99.99 a year for one child1,3. But we found no hints in the software, MIND's guide turns to an adult when a child is stuck, and it stops at grade 86,1. AMP teaches at every problem, finds the level in each part of math, and runs through precalculus.

Try it free

Why AMP

AMP teaches on the screen, at every problem

ST Math teaches through the puzzle, and its feedback is an animation of what the answer does4. We found no hints in the software. For a stuck student, MIND's guide points to an adult's questions, hands-on materials and a few in-game tools, and says not to give the answer6. Modulo's homeschool review notes that some users want more direct instruction or guidance30. AMP gives every problem type a one-step hint and a written lesson with a worked example, and shows the correct answer and worked steps after every answer.

The research: Lessons with worked examples · The research: One-step hints · The research: Feedback after every answer

It starts at the learner's level, strand by strand

We found no placement test in ST Math: a student starts on the Journey for their grade8, and MIND recommends keeping students on their assigned grade7. Moving a struggling child to an earlier grade is a choice an adult makes by hand7,31. In the independent trial, the lowest performers finished under half their grade's content, and the authors suggested they may have needed below-grade work14. AMP places the learner within the first 24 problems and keeps a level in each of 14 strands, and two misses in a row send practice back to what the skill builds on.

The research: Practice at the learner’s level · The research: Mastery, and repair of gaps

AMP measures mastery in numbers and symbols

In ST Math a level counts when every puzzle in it is right, and two wrong answers restart it until 15 tries turn the restart off4,9. In the full program, a post-quiz of typical test questions closes each objective from grade 2, but students move on whatever they score10. The trial's authors suggested that transfer from the game to math tests may be lower than its developers expected14. AMP shows a skill as Strong at four of the last five answers right without help, and 547 of its problem types need a typed number, fraction, line of work, plot or built model.

The research: Mastery, and repair of gaps

Old skills come back on a schedule

ST Math returns to a topic where its fixed sequence spirals back to it4. Mixed Review sits in bonus content after the Journey11, and the family version, ST Math Focus, leaves it out3,5. AMP brings each learned skill back after 6 hours, 1 day, 3 days, 1 week, 2 weeks and a month, mixed with other topics. In a randomized trial of 787 seventh graders, students given mixed, spaced practice scored 62% on the researchers' own test a month later, and those who practiced in blocks scored 38%33.

The research: Spaced, mixed review

One program from counting through precalculus

ST Math covers PreK through grade 8, and MIND calls it a supplemental program1,4. AMP runs from counting through precalculus on one map of 336 skills, so a learner never changes programs at grade 9. It prints unlimited workbooks made for each learner, each with a worked answer key. The only ST Math workbooks we found are fixed practice books for its Texas edition24.

It works on a phone and starts free

MIND says the ST Math student experience does not support phones or Android tablets, and it needs a persistent high-speed connection12. We found no free trial; MIND points families to free sample games13. AMP runs in any current browser on a phone, tablet or computer. Every learner gets 100 answers and 5 workbooks free, with no card.

Side by side

AMPST Math
Price$599 a year or $59 a month for the first child, then $399 or $39 for each more. Two parents practice free. Full refund within 30 days.At home: $99.99 a year or $9.99 a month; each extra student $20 a year or $2 a month3. Schools: by quote2.
Who can buyFamilies, tutors and schools, directly. Free to start without a card: 100 answers and 5 workbooks. Arizona ESA, Arkansas EFA and New Hampshire EFA funds pay for it.Families in the US, Canada and Mexico27, and schools. We found no free trial; MIND offers free sample games13.
RangeCounting through precalculus in one program: 336 skills on one map.PreK through grade 8, as a supplemental program1,4.
Finding the starting pointNo separate test. Placement takes the first 24 problems of practice. After that, every answer adjusts a level in each of 14 strands of math.We found no placement test. A student starts on the Journey for their grade8.
TeachingA one-step hint and a written lesson with a worked example for every problem type. Worked steps after every answer. Narrated lesson films.Visual, mostly wordless puzzles; an animation shows what each answer does4,26. We found no hints; MIND's guide has an adult coach a stuck student6.
What decides the next problemAMP chooses every problem from the learner’s answers: new work just within reach, a prerequisite, or review.A fixed sequence, at the student's own pace4. An adult can assign objectives from any grade25.
MasteryFour of the last five answers right without help. An answer after a hint doesn’t count. Two misses in a row send practice back to what the skill builds on.Every puzzle in a level right; two wrong answers restart it, until 15 tries turn restarts off4,9. Post-quiz scores do not hold students back10.
ReviewScheduled. Learned skills come back after six hours, a day, three days, a week, two weeks and a month, mixed with other topics.Topics spiral back in the fixed sequence4. Mixed Review is bonus content, left out of the family version11,3,5.
PrintUnlimited workbooks made for each learner, each with a worked answer key. Results entered from paper count.Printable Math Mats and classroom sheets, many in Spanish6,20. The only workbooks we found are fixed ones for the Texas edition24.
What the adult has to doNothing to plan, teach or grade. AMP places the learner, chooses each problem, checks it and schedules review.Little to run at home. MIND's guides have an adult coach a stuck child and change the grade by hand6,31.
ReportsThe level in every strand with its likely range, skills, time, and the actual problems behind each number. For teachers, who needs them today.Parents: objectives, puzzle goals and quiz scores22. Teachers: minutes, puzzles per minute and alerts on students23,9.
EvidenceA published rationale (ESSA Tier 4) with the research behind each part, public source code, and outcome studies from 2027, each registered before it starts.Rated Strong by Evidence for ESSA, average +0.072. One independent randomized trial: 0.07 SD after a year, marginally significant14.

What ST Math is

From MIND Education

ST Math is made by MIND Education, a nonprofit founded in 199828. MIND's home page claims 1.6 million students and more than 4,600 schools29. Schools buy it as a PreK to grade 8 supplemental math program1. Families buy ST Math at Home, which runs a streamlined curriculum called ST Math Focus3,5.

A child opens the Journey for their grade, a map of objectives. Each objective holds games, and each game holds levels of 5 to 8 puzzles8,26. A puzzle is a visual, mostly wordless problem: JiJi the penguin is blocked, the child moves objects such as fraction blocks or a number line, and an animation shows whether JiJi gets across4,26,14. In the full program, objectives from grade 2 open and close with a quiz, and the post-quiz uses typical test questions10,5.

MIND's approach is "concepts before symbols"1. In schools, class discussions MIND calls Math Puzzle Talks help students explain and connect what they learned1. The help center ties gains to 60 or more minutes of use a week4.

What ST Math does well

The evidence

ST Math

Evidence for ESSA rates ST Math Strong for grades 3 to 6, based on four studies with an average effect of +0.072. One is an independent randomized trial. The other three were written by MIND or done by WestEd under contract to MIND2,17,18.

The trial, by Rutherford and colleagues (2014), was run by independent researchers without oversight from MIND and funded by a U.S. Institute of Education Sciences grant14,16. It randomized 52 low-performing Southern California schools, and its analysis covered 13,803 students in grades 3 to 5. Classes in ST Math schools were scheduled for two 45-minute sessions a week. After one year the effect on the state math test was 0.07 standard deviations, marginally significant. After two years it was 0.15 and not significant. The abstract calls the effect on math scores negligible14,15. English learners and the lowest performers gained no more than other students14.

WestEd's 2019 study, prepared under contract to MIND, matched grades in 474 schools across 16 states that adopted ST Math with similar grades that did not17. It found 0.13 on scale scores and 0.17 on percent proficient. Those effects are measured against the spread of school-grade averages, not of students, so they are not on the same scale as the trial's 0.07. WestEd notes that districts which chose the program may have differed in other ways, and its larger figures, 0.31 and 0.35, come from the 239 schools that met its usage thresholds17.

A non-experimental Harvard study from 2020, in 13 school systems serving about 230,000 students, compared students whose weekly use rose by more than 10 minutes with similar students whose use stayed flat. It found close to 0.04 standard deviations. In grades 2 to 5, students averaged 49 minutes a week against a recommended 90, and "None of the sites reached the recommended level"19.

AMP

Two findings shape how AMP teaches where ST Math leaves it to the puzzle or the adult. Across 55 studies, worked examples improved math performance with an average effect of g = 0.4835. Across 40 studies of computer-based feedback, feedback that explains averaged 0.49, the correct answer alone 0.32, and right-or-wrong alone 0.0534. AMP puts a worked example in every lesson and the worked steps after every answer, and schedules review on top. We expect that design to show in outcomes. That is our bet, and we have committed to testing it in public.

AMP is new, and its own outcome studies have not run yet. They begin in 2027: growth on a national test against hours of use, then comparison groups, then randomized trials. Each will be registered before it starts and published whatever it finds. Until then, the research behind each part of AMP is laid out in our report, and the code is public.

The research behind AMP

Choose ST Math if

Choose AMP if

Questions

Is ST Math a full math curriculum?

MIND's help center calls it a supplemental math program, and its At Home page says families can use it as part of a homeschool math program or beside another curriculum4,32. The family version leaves out Math Facts, Challenge and Mixed Review3,5. AMP covers counting through precalculus in one program, with lessons, practice and scheduled review.

Is AMP more expensive than ST Math?

Yes. ST Math at Home is $99.99 a year or $9.99 a month for one student, plus $20 a year or $2 a month for each additional student3. AMP is $599 a year or $59 a month for the first child and $399 or $39 for each more, and that covers lessons, hints, scheduled review and unlimited workbooks from counting through precalculus.

Does ST Math work on a phone or an Android tablet?

Not officially. MIND says the student experience does not support phones or Android tablets; it supports Chrome on a computer or Chromebook, Edge on Windows, and Safari on an iPad12. AMP runs in any current browser on a phone, tablet or computer.

Is ST Math proven to work?

Its independent randomized trial found 0.07 standard deviations after one year, marginally significant, and no significant effect after two14. Evidence for ESSA rates it Strong2.

Sources

  1. ST Math (MIND Education)
  2. ST Math (Spatial Temporal Math) (Evidence for ESSA)
  3. ST Math at Home pricing (ST Math help center)
  4. What is ST Math? (ST Math help center)
  5. What is ST Math Focus? (ST Math help center)
  6. Supporting struggling students (ST Math help center)
  7. Supporting students below grade level (ST Math help center)
  8. What is a Journey? (ST Math help center)
  9. Managing Infinite JiJis (ST Math help center)
  10. Pre-quizzes and post-quizzes (ST Math help center)
  11. After the Journey: Bonus, Mixed Review and Challenge (ST Math help center)
  12. Technical requirements (ST Math help center)
  13. Demos and trials (ST Math help center)
  14. Rutherford et al. (2014), A randomized trial of an elementary school mathematics software intervention: Spatial-Temporal Math, Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness 7(4)
  15. Rutherford et al. (2014), abstract (UNC Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute)
  16. IES award R305A090527, Spatial-Temporal Mathematics at scale (Institute of Education Sciences)
  17. Wendt, Rice & Nakamoto (2019), A cross-state evaluation of MIND Research Institute's ST Math program, WestEd
  18. Wendt, Rice & Nakamoto (2014), Evaluation of the MIND Research Institute's ST Math program in California, WestEd
  19. Scherer et al. (2020), Exploring ST Math's implementation and impact, Harvard CEPR Proving Ground (copy on MIND's research portal)
  20. Spanish resources (ST Math help center)
  21. Quiz data, in English and Spanish (ST Math help center)
  22. ST Math at Home progress report (ST Math help center)
  23. Student usage report (ST Math help center)
  24. ST Math Texas workbooks (ST Math help center)
  25. ST Math at Home assignments (ST Math help center)
  26. Games, levels and puzzles (ST Math help center)
  27. Where ST Math at Home is available (ST Math help center)
  28. About MIND Education
  29. MIND Education home page
  30. ST Math review (Modulo, 2024)
  31. Changing an ST Math at Home student's grade Journey (ST Math help center)
  32. ST Math at Home (MIND Education)
  33. Rohrer, Dedrick, Hartwig & Cheung (2020), A randomized controlled trial of interleaved mathematics practice (What Works Clearinghouse review)
  34. Van der Kleij, Feskens & Eggen (2015), Effects of feedback in a computer-based learning environment, Review of Educational Research 85(4)
  35. Barbieri, Miller-Cotto, Clerjuste & Chawla (2023), A meta-analysis of the worked examples effect on mathematics performance, Educational Psychology Review 35
  36. What Works Clearinghouse (2021), Assisting students struggling with mathematics: Intervention in the elementary grades

Checked November 2026.

ST Math is a trademark of its owner. AMP is not affiliated with it. Found an error? Write to skylar@corpora.inc.

More comparisons

All comparisons · AMP · Research