AMP vs Math with Confidence
Math with Confidence is a well-reviewed K-6 curriculum that a parent teaches from a script, with games and household objects, for a fraction of AMP's price1,2,3. The parent picks the grade, teaches each lesson, checks the pages and decides when to review2,6. AMP does those jobs at every answer, from counting through precalculus, and still prints paper.
Why AMP
AMP teaches every problem, with or without an adult
Math with Confidence is taught by the parent, every lesson. The adult reads the lesson, gathers objects, prints and cuts the paper pieces, teaches, and checks the workbook2,4. Cathy Duffy rates the parent instruction it needs as moderate to high2. In AMP every problem type has a one-step hint and a written lesson with a worked example, and worked steps follow every answer, so a learner can keep going on a day the adult is busy.
The research: Lessons with worked examples · The research: One-step hints
AMP finds the level in each part of math
Math with Confidence has no placement test that we found. The author's guidance is to use the grade that matches the child's age, and her list of skills each grade assumes is the check1,6. For grade 5 that list includes multiplication and division facts in about three seconds, and long division6. AMP places the learner within the first 24 problems and keeps a level in each of 14 strands, with no separate test. A child ahead in geometry and behind in fractions gets work at both levels.
The research: Practice at the learner’s level
Every answer is checked and explained at once
In Math with Confidence the parent checks the workbook pages, and the built-in checks are the unit Checkpoints and, from grade 3, Unit Wrap-ups2. AMP marks every answer the moment it is given and shows the correct answer and the worked steps. A meta-analysis of 40 studies of computer-based feedback found average effects of 0.49 for feedback that explains, 0.32 for the correct answer alone and 0.05 for right or wrong only. These are averages by feedback type across ages and subjects, and effects were lower in primary and high school10.
The research: Feedback after every answer
Old skills return on a schedule
Math with Confidence uses warm-ups and spiral review to keep earlier skills fresh2. The pages and reviews we read state no fixed schedule for it1,2. AMP brings each learned skill back after 6 hours, then 1, 3, 7, 14 and 30 days, mixed with other topics, and a miss restarts the clock. In a randomized trial with 787 seventh graders, mixed practice, which was also spaced, scored 62% on the researchers' own test a month later, against 38% for practice in blocks9.
The research: Spaced, mixed review
A stuck skill leads back to what it needs
At the end of each unit, a Math with Confidence Checkpoint lists the objectives the child should have met, and the parent decides whether to review or move on2. For shaky facts, the author suggests adding five minutes of daily practice6. In AMP two misses in a row on a skill send practice to the skills it builds on. A skill counts as Strong only after four of the last five answers are right without help.
The research: Mastery, and repair of gaps
One program from counting to precalculus, on paper too
Math with Confidence ends at grade 6, with one guide and fixed workbooks for each grade1. AMP runs from counting through precalculus in one program, so there is no new program to choose after grade 6. It prints unlimited workbooks made from each learner's own record, with a worked answer key, and results entered from paper count toward the level.
Side by side
| AMP | Math with Confidence | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $599 a year or $59 a month for the first child, then $399 or $39 for each more. Two parents practice free. Full refund within 30 days. | Books, no subscription. Publisher prices, November 2026: kindergarten guide $27.96 to $33.96, workbook $15.96 to $20.363. Guide reusable for siblings4. |
| Who can buy | Families, tutors and schools, directly. Free to start without a card: 100 answers and 5 workbooks. Arizona ESA, Arkansas EFA and New Hampshire EFA funds pay for it. | Anyone. Print from Amazon, Well-Trained Mind Press and other booksellers; PDFs only from the publisher1,5. |
| Range | Counting through precalculus in one program: 336 skills on one map. | Kindergarten through grade 61. |
| Finding the starting point | No separate test. Placement takes the first 24 problems of practice. After that, every answer adjusts a level in each of 14 strands of math. | No placement test found. The author advises the grade that matches the child's age, with a list of skills the grade assumes1,6. |
| Teaching | A one-step hint and a written lesson with a worked example for every problem type. Worked steps after every answer. Narrated lesson films. | The parent teaches from a scripted guide, with objects, games and picture books2,5. |
| What decides the next problem | AMP chooses every problem from the learner’s answers: new work just within reach, a prerequisite, or review. | A fixed sequence of units. The parent decides whether to review or move on2. |
| Mastery | Four of the last five answers right without help. An answer after a hint doesn’t count. Two misses in a row send practice back to what the skill builds on. | Several weeks per topic. A Checkpoint lists what the child should know; the parent judges it1,2. |
| Review | Scheduled. Learned skills come back after six hours, a day, three days, a week, two weeks and a month, mixed with other topics. | Warm-ups and spiral review. No fixed review schedule in the materials we read2. |
| Unlimited workbooks made for each learner, each with a worked answer key. Results entered from paper count. | All print or PDF: one guide and one or two fixed workbooks per grade1,4. | |
| What the adult has to do | Nothing to plan, teach or grade. AMP places the learner, chooses each problem, checks it and schedules review. | Teaches each lesson, gathers objects, prints and cuts paper pieces, checks pages. Grade 5 pilot: 10 to 15 parent-led minutes a lesson2,6. |
| Reports | The level in every strand with its likely range, skills, time, and the actual problems behind each number. For teachers, who needs them today. | None built in. The parent grades; Checkpoints and Unit Wrap-ups are the assessments2. |
| Evidence | A published rationale (ESSA Tier 4) with the research behind each part, public source code, and outcome studies from 2027, each registered before it starts. | No entry in Evidence for ESSA or the What Works Clearinghouse. An author-run pilot of 77 students, scored against test norms, has no comparison group7,8,12. |
What Math with Confidence is
From Well-Trained Mind Press
Math with Confidence is a homeschool math curriculum for kindergarten through grade 6, written by Kate Snow and published by Well-Trained Mind Press1,2. Each grade has an Instructor Guide for the parent and a student workbook. From grade 3 the workbook comes in two parts, A and B1. Print copies sell through Amazon, Well-Trained Mind Press and other booksellers. PDFs come only from the publisher1,5.
A lesson is the parent and child together. The guide is scripted, so a parent can open it and teach1,4. In the early grades a lesson starts with a few minutes of warm-up and review, then 5 to 10 minutes of hands-on teaching, then a short workbook page2. Kindergarten through grade 2 has four core lessons a week and an enrichment day2. From grade 3 the parent leads the activities and the child then practices alone. In the fifth-grade pilot, families spent 30 to 45 minutes a lesson, 10 to 15 of them led by the parent2,6.
The teaching uses manipulatives, ten-frames, games, scavenger hunts, pretend play and picture-book suggestions2,5. Each unit stays on one topic for several weeks and ends with a Checkpoint that lists what the child should know1,2.
What Math with Confidence does well
- A script a parent can open and teach from. One reviewer says it is not in any way "dumbed-down"4. Cathy Duffy lists it among her Top Picks2.
- Hands-on and playful: games, pretend play, scavenger hunts and objects from around the house2. AMP has no games, and the models a learner moves on screen are limited to a few problem types.
- It costs far less. At Well-Trained Mind Press the kindergarten guide and workbook together are on sale from $43.92 in total, depending on format, and the guide can be reused for a younger sibling3,4. AMP is $599 a year for the first child.
- No screen is needed. The workbooks are in full color, with alternate pages for color-blind students4.
The evidence
Math with Confidence
Math with Confidence has no entry in Evidence for ESSA or the What Works Clearinghouse (checked November 2026)7,8. We did not find an independent outcome study in the sources we read.
The author's pages report a pilot in which 75% of students "scored at the 98th or 99th percentile on a standardized test"1,5. The author's follow-up article gives the details: 77 fifth-grade students took the math section of the California Achievement Test online in spring 2024, and the author paid for the testing12. Scores are set against test norms, not a comparison group of children using another program. The author calls it an informal survey, not a peer-reviewed study, and lists her own caveats: pilot families are committed and get extra support, they chose to take part, and other programs may do as well12. Scores like these show how those children did. Without a comparison group they cannot show what the curriculum added.
AMP
AMP is built on findings about how math is learned. Worked examples: across 55 studies, mostly on researchers' own tests, they improved math performance with an average effect of g = 0.4811. AMP has one for every problem type, beside the problem, and shows worked steps after every answer. The two jobs a printed book leaves to the adult, mixed review on a schedule and an explanation after every answer, rest on the trial and the review cited above9,10. We expect a program that does them at every problem to show it in outcomes, and we have committed to measuring that in public.
AMP is new, and its own outcome studies have not run yet. They begin in 2027: growth on a national test against hours of use, then comparison groups, then randomized trials. Each will be registered before it starts and published whatever it finds. Until then, the research behind each part of AMP is laid out in our report, and the code is public.
Choose Math with Confidence if
- You want to teach math yourself, at the table, from a script.
- Your child is young and learns best with objects, games and play beside you.
- You want math with no screen.
- You want a kindergarten year for about $44 to $54 in books at sale prices, with a guide you can reuse for siblings.
Choose AMP if
- You want your child to practice and learn on days you cannot teach.
- You are not sure which grade fits, or your child is ahead in one part of math and behind in another.
- You want every answer checked and explained, and old skills brought back on a schedule without planning it.
- Your child is past grade 6, or soon will be, and you want one program through precalculus.
- You love your book and want AMP beside it, to find gaps and print practice made for your child.
Questions
Is Math with Confidence cheaper than AMP?
Yes, by a lot. At Well-Trained Mind Press the kindergarten guide and workbook together are on sale from $43.92 in total, depending on format, and the guide can be reused for siblings3,4. AMP costs $599 a year or $59 a month for the first child, and that price buys placement, a chosen next problem, checked answers, scheduled review and printed workbooks from counting through precalculus.
Can we use AMP alongside Math with Confidence?
Yes. A family can keep teaching lessons from the book and use AMP for practice: it finds the level in each strand, checks every answer and brings old skills back on a schedule. Its workbooks print on paper, and results entered from paper count.
Does Math with Confidence have a placement test?
We found none. The author advises the grade that matches the child's age and lists the skills each grade assumes, such as multiplication and division facts in about three seconds for grade 51,6. AMP places a learner inside practice, within the first 24 problems.
What comes after Math with Confidence grade 6?
The series ends at grade 61. AMP continues through grades 7 and 8, Algebra 1, Geometry, Algebra 2 and Precalculus in the same program.
Is AMP proven to work better than Math with Confidence?
No. Math with Confidence has no entry in Evidence for ESSA or the What Works Clearinghouse7,8, and AMP has no outcome study yet. AMP's first studies begin in 2027 and will be published whatever they find.
Sources
- Math with Confidence (Kate's Homeschool Math)
- Math with Confidence review (Cathy Duffy Reviews)
- Math (Well-Trained Mind Press)
- Math with Confidence curriculum review (Teacher Tutor Mom)
- Math with Confidence homeschool math curriculum (Kate's Homeschool Math)
- Fifth Grade Math with Confidence (Kate's Homeschool Math)
- Evidence for ESSA search: Math with Confidence
- What Works Clearinghouse intervention reports
- Rohrer, Dedrick, Hartwig & Cheung (2020), A randomized controlled trial of interleaved mathematics practice (What Works Clearinghouse review)
- Van der Kleij, Feskens & Eggen (2015), Effects of feedback in a computer-based learning environment, Review of Educational Research 85(4)
- Barbieri, Miller-Cotto, Clerjuste & Chawla (2023), A meta-analysis of the worked examples effect on mathematics performance, Educational Psychology Review 35
- How do Math with Confidence students perform on standardized tests? (Kate's Homeschool Math)
Checked November 2026.
Math with Confidence is a trademark of its owner. AMP is not affiliated with it. Found an error? Write to skylar@corpora.inc.
More comparisons
- AMP vs Math-U-See: Math-U-See is taught by a parent with blocks and video. AMP checks every answer and picks the next problem itself.
- AMP vs RightStart Mathematics: RightStart is taught by a parent with an abacus and card games. AMP places, checks and schedules review itself.
- AMP vs Saxon Math: Saxon prints the same mixed review for every child; AMP times each skill's review to the learner's answers.