AMP vs Saxon Math

Saxon Math has built review of earlier lessons into every day's practice for decades, and a homeschool kit costs a fraction of AMP's yearly price1,2,4. That review is printed in the same order for every child, and a wrong answer waits until an adult checks it against the solutions manual9. AMP times each skill's review to the learner, checks every answer the moment it is given, and still prints paper.

Try it free

Why AMP

Review timed to each learner, not to the page

HMH describes Saxon's practice as distributed through the year, with continual review of earlier lessons; every problem set mixes new work with old1,11. The mix is printed in the book, so every child meets an old topic at the same point, whether it came easily or barely. AMP brings each learned skill back after 6 hours, then 1 day, 3 days, 1 week, 2 weeks and a month, mixed with other topics. A miss starts that skill's schedule again.

The research: Spaced, mixed review

Every answer checked and explained at once

In Saxon the parent checks daily work and tests by hand, with a solutions manual9. In the Algebra 1 kit, test problems have no step-by-step solutions unless the family buys the Saxon Teacher CD-ROMs6. AMP checks every answer exactly and shows right or wrong, the correct answer and the worked steps before the next problem. Feedback that explains is the kind with the largest effects in studies of computer-based feedback18.

The research: Feedback after every answer

Each problem chosen from the learner's answers

Every Saxon student does the same lessons in the book's order, with about 30 mixed problems a lesson in grades 4 and 5 and in the 4th-edition algebra books9,10. The adult decides when to skip ahead or slow down. AMP keeps a level in each of 14 strands and picks every next problem from the answers so far: new work, a prerequisite, or review. While a learner is still climbing, every second problem reaches higher.

The research: Practice at the learner’s level · The research: Mastery, and repair of gaps

Repeated misses lead back to the missing piece

Saxon's test books include a Test Analysis Form that maps missed test problems to the lessons that taught them. The adult does the reteaching9,10. In AMP, two misses in a row on a skill send practice to the skills it builds on. A skill counts as strong only after four of the last five answers are right without help. No one has to spot the gap first.

The research: Mastery, and repair of gaps

Help on the problem, not a lesson number

We found no hints in the Saxon materials we read. Its newest books print beside each mixed problem the number of the lesson that taught it, so a student who misses one can look it up9. Every AMP problem type has a one-step hint that never gives the answer and a written lesson with a worked example, right beside the problem. Narrated lesson films cover a growing share of problem types.

The research: One-step hints · The research: Lessons with worked examples · The research: Narrated lesson films

Workbooks made for this learner, with worked keys

A Saxon kit is the same printed book for every student5. AMP prints unlimited workbooks built from the learner's own record, with a section of skills due for review and an answer key that works every problem. Results entered from paper count toward the learner's level. A family can keep teaching Saxon's lessons and use AMP for practice and review.

Side by side

AMPSaxon Math
Price$599 a year or $59 a month for the first child, then $399 or $39 for each more. Two parents practice free. Full refund within 30 days.Homeschool kits $94.95 to $159.95 a course at Rainbow Resource4. Saxon Teacher CD-ROM for Math 5/4: $233.257. School prices by request1.
Who can buyFamilies, tutors and schools, directly. Free to start without a card: 100 answers and 5 workbooks. Arizona ESA, Arkansas EFA and New Hampshire EFA funds pay for it.Families, through Rainbow Resource, HMH's homeschool partner3. Schools request information from HMH1.
RangeCounting through precalculus in one program: 336 skills on one map.Kindergarten through calculus, plus physics4.
Finding the starting pointNo separate test. Placement takes the first 24 problems of practice. After that, every answer adjusts a level in each of 14 strands of math.A placement test linked from Rainbow Resource's kit page5. The adult picks the book.
TeachingA one-step hint and a written lesson with a worked example for every problem type. Worked steps after every answer. Narrated lesson films.A written lesson on one small new idea, with worked examples9,10. In kindergarten through grade 3, a parent teaches from a scripted manual8. Video costs extra7.
What decides the next problemAMP chooses every problem from the learner’s answers: new work just within reach, a prerequisite, or review.The next lesson in the book, about 120 per book, in order5. The adult sets the pace.
MasteryFour of the last five answers right without help. An answer after a hint doesn’t count. Two misses in a row send practice back to what the skill builds on.No per-skill mastery rule in the materials we read. A cumulative test after every five lessons11.
ReviewScheduled. Learned skills come back after six hours, a day, three days, a week, two weeks and a month, mixed with other topics.Mixed review of earlier lessons in every problem set, in the same order for every student1,11.
PrintUnlimited workbooks made for each learner, each with a worked answer key. Results entered from paper count.All print: textbook, tests and worksheets, and a solutions manual5. The same book for every child.
What the adult has to doNothing to plan, teach or grade. AMP places the learner, chooses each problem, checks it and schedules review.Leads every lesson in kindergarten through grade 38. From grade 4, checks daily work and tests by hand9.
ReportsThe level in every strand with its likely range, skills, time, and the actual problems behind each number. For teachers, who needs them today.No reports beyond paper tests. A Test Analysis Form maps missed test problems to lessons9,10.
EvidenceA published rationale (ESSA Tier 4) with the research behind each part, public source code, and outcome studies from 2027, each registered before it starts.What Works Clearinghouse: mixed effects, grades 1 to 8 (2017)11. Evidence for ESSA: Promising, grades 1 and 2, +0.1113. Algebra I: no discernible effects12.

What Saxon Math is

From HMH (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt)

Saxon Math is a print curriculum published by HMH. It began with John Saxon, who taught math at Rose State College for 14 years, and HMH says Saxon textbooks have been used since 19812. HMH lists its school editions without prices and asks schools to request information1. Families buy homeschool kits, from kindergarten through calculus, at Rainbow Resource, which HMH names as its homeschool partner3,4.

From grade 4, a lesson opens with facts and mental math, then teaches one small new idea in text with worked examples9,10. Practice on that idea follows, then a mixed set of earlier work: about 30 problems a lesson in grades 4 and 5 and in the 4th-edition algebra books9,10. A cumulative test follows every fifth lesson10,11. A book holds about 120 lessons5. Most students read the lessons on their own, and the parent checks daily work and tests, with a solutions manual9.

Kindergarten through grade 3 work differently. A parent teaches each lesson from a scripted manual, usually with manipulatives, after a daily Meeting on time, money and counting8. The kits are books: a text, tests and a solutions manual5,6. Video lessons are sold separately, such as HMH's Saxon Teacher CD-ROMs7.

What Saxon Math does well

The evidence

Saxon Math

Saxon Math has real outcome research, all of it in schools. The What Works Clearinghouse's May 2017 report on Saxon's primary courses found 26 eligible studies. Five met its standards, all with reservations, covering 8,855 students in grades 1 to 8. Its rating is mixed effects, with an average gain of 8 percentile points, ranging from −1 to +16 across studies11.

The only randomized trial of the five, by Agodini and colleagues for the Institute of Education Sciences, assigned four curricula to schools at random11. After two years, second graders using Saxon scored 0.25 standard deviations above those using Investigations, and about the same as those using Math Expressions (−0.02) or Scott Foresman–Addison Wesley (0.00). Pooled, the effect was +0.07 and not statistically significant. Saxon teachers also gave about six hours of math a week, against about five in the other curricula11. Evidence for ESSA rates Saxon Math Promising for grades 1 and 2 on a 2010 paper from the same trial, against Scott Foresman–Addison Wesley, with an average effect of +0.1113.

The other four studies compare groups that were not assigned at random. Their effects ran from +0.11 to +0.41, and none was statistically significant as the Clearinghouse calculated it11. For Algebra I it found no discernible effects (two studies, 198 students), and no study of Saxon Geometry, Algebra II or Advanced Math met its standards12. We found no outcome study of Saxon used at home in either the Clearinghouse's or Evidence for ESSA's records.

HMH's own ESSA summaries claim more: Strong for kindergarten through grade 5, and Promising for grades 9 to 1214,15. The Strong claim reports the same trial's one-year result for second graders against Scott Foresman–Addison Wesley14; after two years, the Clearinghouse found no difference between the two (0.00)11. The high-school claim rests on a 1997 study of 120 juniors at two Georgia high schools, which the Clearinghouse found does not meet its standards15,12.

AMP

Saxon's central idea has strong research behind it, and AMP keeps it. In a randomized trial with 787 seventh graders that meets What Works Clearinghouse standards without reservations, mixed and spaced practice scored 62% on the researchers' test a month later, against 38% for practice in blocks16. Spacing research adds a second rule: the best gap between reviews grows with how long the material must last, in studies of verbal recall17. A printed book fixes those gaps for everyone. AMP widens them for each skill and each learner, and restarts them after a miss. We expect review timed to the learner to beat review timed to the page. That is our bet, and we have committed to testing AMP in public.

AMP is new, and its own outcome studies have not run yet. They begin in 2027: growth on a national test against hours of use, then comparison groups, then randomized trials. Each will be registered before it starts and published whatever it finds. Until then, the research behind each part of AMP is laid out in our report, and the code is public.

The research behind AMP

Choose Saxon Math if

Choose AMP if

Questions

Can I use AMP with Saxon Math?

Yes. A family can keep teaching Saxon's lessons and use AMP for practice and review. AMP places the learner within the first 24 problems and keeps a level in each part of math, schedules review for each skill, and prints workbooks with worked answer keys.

Is AMP more expensive than Saxon Math?

Yes. A Saxon homeschool kit costs $94.95 to $159.95 a course at Rainbow Resource4. AMP is $599 a year or $59 a month for the first child. That price covers placement, every problem chosen and checked, scheduled review, unlimited workbooks, and counting through precalculus.

Does Saxon Math work?

In the What Works Clearinghouse's May 2017 review, Saxon had mixed effects in grades 1 to 8, with an average gain of 8 percentile points11. Evidence for ESSA rates it Promising for grades 1 and 213. For Algebra I the Clearinghouse found no discernible effects12.

Is Saxon Math spiral or mastery?

Saxon teaches in small steps and reviews them continually: each lesson adds one new idea, and every problem set mixes it with earlier lessons1,11. AMP does both. A skill counts as strong after four of the last five answers are right without help, and then it comes back on a schedule.

Does AMP go as far as Saxon Math?

No. Saxon runs through calculus and physics4. AMP runs from counting through precalculus in one program.

Sources

  1. Saxon Math program page (HMH)
  2. John Saxon (HMH)
  3. Homeschool (HMH)
  4. Saxon Math homeschool kits (Rainbow Resource Center)
  5. Saxon Math 5/4 Homeschool Kit, 3rd edition (Rainbow Resource Center)
  6. Saxon Algebra 1 Homeschool Kit with Solutions Manual, 4th edition (Rainbow Resource Center)
  7. Saxon Math 5/4 Homeschool Saxon Teacher CD-ROM (HMH)
  8. Saxon Math K-3 review (Cathy Duffy Reviews)
  9. Saxon Math 5/4 through Calculus review (Cathy Duffy Reviews)
  10. Saxon Math Intermediate series review (Cathy Duffy Reviews)
  11. What Works Clearinghouse (2017), Saxon Math intervention report, Primary Mathematics
  12. What Works Clearinghouse (2016), Saxon Math intervention report, Secondary Mathematics
  13. Saxon Math (Evidence for ESSA)
  14. Saxon Math K-5 ESSA evidence overview (HMH)
  15. Saxon Math 9-12 ESSA evidence overview (HMH)
  16. Rohrer et al. (2020), A randomized controlled trial of interleaved mathematics practice (What Works Clearinghouse review)
  17. Cepeda et al. (2006), Distributed practice in verbal recall tasks
  18. Van der Kleij et al. (2015), Effects of feedback in a computer-based learning environment

Checked November 2026.

Saxon Math is a trademark of its owner. AMP is not affiliated with it. Found an error? Write to skylar@corpora.inc.

More comparisons

All comparisons · AMP · Research