AMP vs Prodigy Math
Prodigy Math is free for schools, children enjoy it, and teachers say it keeps a class engaged5,9. Its questions sit inside a game, and in a study Prodigy ran, fourth graders spent on average about five and a half hours in a whole school year answering them13. AMP is all math: every answer is checked and explained, and it sets the next problem, from counting through precalculus.
Why AMP
Every minute in AMP is math
Prodigy's questions sit inside a game world of battles, gear and pets10. In one 19-minute session of the free home version, the complaint Fairplay (then CCFC) filed with the FTC in 2021 counted four math problems10. In a study Prodigy ran, fourth graders averaged 5.42 hours answering questions across a school year13. In AMP one problem follows another, each chosen from the last answer.
The research: Practice at the learner’s level
A wrong answer is followed by teaching
In a 2020 evaluation funded by Prodigy, Johns Hopkins researchers and teachers noted "the lack of remediation and actual teaching"9,10. Prodigy has since added video lessons and hint bubbles to the question screen4,12. Common Sense Media's review notes limited feedback for incorrect answers11. AMP shows the correct answer and the worked steps after every answer. Every problem type has a one-step hint that never gives the answer and a written lesson with a worked example.
The research: Feedback after every answer · The research: Lessons with worked examples · The research: One-step hints
A learned skill has a rule and a schedule
We found no published mastery rule and no scheduled review of earlier skills in the Prodigy pages we checked1,4,6. In AMP a skill is Strong when four of the last five answers are right without help, and two misses in a row send practice back to what it builds on. Learned skills come back after 6 hours, 1 day, 3 days, 1 week, 2 weeks and a month, mixed with other topics. In a randomized trial with 787 seventh graders, mixed and spaced practice scored 62% against 38% on the researchers' test a month later18.
The research: Mastery, and repair of gaps · The research: Spaced, mixed review
In AMP, progress comes only from math
Prodigy's questions are free for everyone, and memberships change the game around them: members earn 2x to 3x treasure-track rewards, and Plus and Ultra add up to 720 Magicoin a month2,3. Fairplay's 2021 complaint alleged that a member with the same number of correct answers reached a higher wizard level, and counted 16 membership ads in that 19-minute session10. Prodigy told Education Week it mentions memberships sparingly and that 95 percent of players use the free version12. In AMP, points come only from a right answer given without help, and student devices carry no ads and no shop.
A level for each part of math
Prodigy sets question difficulty from a grade: the one the student or teacher picks, the placement test's, and a grade its algorithm assesses from recent answers13. Its study reports that algorithm grade as one number per student13. AMP keeps a separate level in each of 14 strands of math, so a strength in geometry never hides a gap in fractions.
The research: Practice at the learner’s level
From counting to precalculus, and on paper
Prodigy Math covers grades 1 to 81. AMP runs from counting in kindergarten through precalculus, 336 skills on one map. Prodigy members can print curated worksheets7. AMP prints unlimited workbooks made from the learner's own practice, each with a worked answer key, and results entered from paper count toward the learner's level.
Side by side
| AMP | Prodigy Math | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $599 a year or $59 a month for the first child, then $399 or $39 for each more. Two parents practice free. Full refund within 30 days. | Questions free. Memberships: Core $9.95 a month or $58.95 a year; Plus $14.95 or $88.95; Ultra $19.95 or $118.952. 25% off for siblings3. |
| Who can buy | Families, tutors and schools, directly. Free to start without a card: 100 answers and 5 workbooks. Arizona ESA, Arkansas EFA and New Hampshire EFA funds pay for it. | Teachers and schools at no cost, including training5. Families play free or buy a membership2. |
| Range | Counting through precalculus in one program: 336 skills on one map. | Math for grades 1 to 8, with over 1,500 skills, its teacher page says1,4. |
| Finding the starting point | No separate test. Placement takes the first 24 problems of practice. After that, every answer adjusts a level in each of 14 strands of math. | A placement test the first time a student plays sets a starting grade4. Teachers can also get a progress snapshot twice a year1. |
| Teaching | A one-step hint and a written lesson with a worked example for every problem type. Worked steps after every answer. Narrated lesson films. | Video lessons, hint bubbles and read-aloud on the question screen4. No written lessons or worked explanations after each answer found in the pages we checked1,4. |
| What decides the next problem | AMP chooses every problem from the learner’s answers: new work just within reach, a prerequisite, or review. | Difficulty follows a grade: chosen, from the placement test, or assessed from recent answers. The algorithm brings in prerequisite or harder skills13. Teachers can assign skills4. |
| Mastery | Four of the last five answers right without help. An answer after a hint doesn’t count. Two misses in a row send practice back to what the skill builds on. | No published mastery rule found1,6. A student who misses gets a second try13. |
| Review | Scheduled. Learned skills come back after six hours, a day, three days, a week, two weeks and a month, mixed with other topics. | No scheduled review of earlier skills found in its published materials1,4. |
| Unlimited workbooks made for each learner, each with a worked answer key. Results entered from paper count. | Members can print curated worksheets based on their Practice Areas report7. No answer keys found in the pages we checked7. | |
| What the adult has to do | Nothing to plan, teach or grade. AMP places the learner, chooses each problem, checks it and schedules review. | Little to prepare9. Teachers can set assignments, tests, goals and in-game rewards4. Parents can set goals and send rewards6. |
| Reports | The level in every strand with its likely range, skills, time, and the actual problems behind each number. For teachers, who needs them today. | Free teacher reports by strand and skill, and monthly report cards for parents4,6. Members get more, including Frustration Detection on Plus and Ultra7. |
| Evidence | A published rationale (ESSA Tier 4) with the research behind each part, public source code, and outcome studies from 2027, each registered before it starts. | Studies run or paid for by Prodigy, none randomized9,10,13,14. Evidence for ESSA lists no qualifying study16. |
What Prodigy Math is
From Prodigy Education
Prodigy Math is a fantasy game for grades 1 to 8 from Prodigy Education1,8. Its teacher page says almost 800,000 teachers in more than 70,000 schools trust it4. Schools and teachers pay nothing, and families can play free2,5. Prodigy calls it a supplemental tool, used beside classroom teaching5,13.
A student walks a wizard avatar through the game world. Meeting a monster starts a battle, and casting a spell takes a right answer to a math question. Wins earn coins, gear and pets10. A placement test runs the first time a student plays. After that an algorithm adjusts difficulty from recent answers and brings in prerequisite or harder skills4,13. The question screen offers video lessons, hint bubbles and read-aloud, and teachers can assign skills, run assessments and set class goals and rewards4.
Prodigy says optional purchases by parents fund the whole program5. Members get more in-game currency and rewards, member-only areas, extra parent reports and printable worksheets3,7.
What Prodigy Math does well
- Children enjoy it. In the Johns Hopkins evaluation, students nearly unanimously said Prodigy made math easier and more fun, and teachers were emphatic about engagement9. The Android app holds 4.7 stars from about 69,000 reviews8.
- Free for every teacher and school, with free training and Clever, ClassLink and Google sign-in5. A teacher can start without a budget. AMP's school pilot is free for 30 days, then paid.
- Far lower prices for families: the questions are free, and Core costs $58.95 a year2. AMP costs $599 a year for the first child.
- An Android app, parent apps for iOS and Android, and read-aloud on the question screen4,6,8. AMP has no app in the stores and does not read problems aloud.
- Outcome studies Prodigy can point to. They were run or paid for by Prodigy and none is randomized9,10,13,14, but they exist.
The evidence
Prodigy Math
Prodigy's page for administrators says it has been independently evaluated and meets ESSA Tier 35. The Tier 3 sign-off we found sits in a study Prodigy ran itself: 448 fourth graders in one southern U.S. district in 2018–19, with no comparison group13. Students averaged 5.42 hours and 662 questions for the year. Accuracy in the game correlated with state test scores (r = .44), the number of questions answered much less (r = .12), and two Johns Hopkins researchers wrote that they believe the study meets Tier 313. The authors say causal claims cannot be made. In our view, accuracy largely reflects what a child already knew, so a link like this cannot show that the game taught the math.
Johns Hopkins' Center for Research and Reform in Education evaluated Prodigy in seven schools of one district, 577 K–5 students, with funding from Prodigy9,10. The design was correlational. For fourth graders, each extra question answered was linked to 0.00113 more points on the Texas state test, roughly 888 questions for one point. Questions answered at home showed no significant link, and students who used it most did not do significantly better than middle users9,10.
The research page's headline, up to 5x greater improvement with heavy use15, comes from a company study in California that compared school grades by how much they used Prodigy14. Its authors call the effects small, found no significant difference within cohorts, and write that the findings do not qualify for ESSA Tier II14. Prodigy's 2025 state reports, such as one on Texas grade 3, compare high-usage schools with the state average, with no matched comparison group17.
Evidence for ESSA, run by the same Johns Hopkins center, lists Prodigy as "No studies met inclusion requirements"16. Every study we found was run or paid for by Prodigy, none is randomized, and most compare heavy users with lighter ones. Students who use a program most often differ from the rest before they start.
AMP
AMP is built on findings that have held up in research. Across 40 studies of computer-based feedback, feedback that explains averaged an effect of 0.49, the correct answer alone 0.32, and marking right or wrong only 0.0519. Mixed, spaced practice scored 62% against 38% a month later in a randomized trial that meets What Works Clearinghouse standards without reservations18. We expect a program that spends every minute on problems, and explains every one, to do more for a child's math than practice set inside a game. That is our belief, and we have committed to testing it in public.
AMP is new, and its own outcome studies have not run yet. They begin in 2027: growth on a national test against hours of use, then comparison groups, then randomized trials. Each will be registered before it starts and published whatever it finds. Until then, the research behind each part of AMP is laid out in our report, and the code is public.
Choose Prodigy Math if
- You teach grades 1 to 8 and want a free practice station that takes little preparation5,9.
- Your child practices math gladly inside a game world, and that matters more to you than how much math fits in an hour.
- You want to spend under $60 a year, or nothing at all2.
- You need an Android app, or questions read aloud4,8.
Choose AMP if
- You want every minute of practice to be math, with no game world, shop or ads.
- You want every miss explained with worked steps, and a lesson one tap away.
- You want a clear rule for when a skill is learned, and review that brings it back on a schedule.
- Your child is in kindergarten or past grade 8.
- You want printed workbooks made from your child's own practice, with answer keys.
Questions
Is Prodigy Math free?
Its math questions are free, and schools pay nothing2,5. Memberships cost $58.95 to $118.95 a year, or $9.95 to $19.95 a month, and add game rewards, member areas, extra reports and printable worksheets2,3,7.
Why does AMP cost more than Prodigy?
AMP is $599 a year or $59 a month for the first child, and $399 or $39 for each more, with a full refund within 30 days. The price buys a program that finds the level in each strand, chooses and explains every problem, schedules review, prints workbooks and runs from counting through precalculus. The first 100 answers and 5 workbooks are free, with no card.
Does Prodigy Math work?
Every study we found was run or paid for by Prodigy, and none is randomized9,10,13,14. The Johns Hopkins evaluation linked roughly 888 questions to one point on the Texas state test9,10. Evidence for ESSA lists Prodigy without a rating16.
My child loves Prodigy. Can we use AMP too?
Yes. They are separate programs. AMP places the learner within the first 24 problems and keeps a level in each part of math, and the first 100 answers are free.
Does AMP have games or rewards like Prodigy?
No. AMP has no game world, avatars or shop. A right answer given without help earns 1 XP and fills part of that skill's bar, and small animations mark progress.
Sources
- Prodigy Math product page and FAQ (Prodigy Education)
- Prodigy membership prices for parents (Prodigy Education)
- Prodigy memberships: plans, comparison and FAQ (Prodigy Education)
- Prodigy for teachers (Prodigy Education)
- Prodigy for administrators (Prodigy Education)
- Prodigy for parents (Prodigy Education)
- Choosing a Prodigy membership (Prodigy blog, December 2024)
- Prodigy Math: Kids Game (Google Play)
- Johns Hopkins Center for Research and Reform in Education (January 2020), Evaluation of Prodigy: Key Findings
- Fairplay/CCFC (2021), request for FTC investigation of Prodigy
- Prodigy Math Game review (Common Sense Media)
- Popular interactive math game Prodigy is target of complaint to Federal Trade Commission (Education Week, February 2021)
- Chen, DeSimone & Mohammed (2020), Evaluation of Prodigy: a correlational study, with the CRRE Tier 3 review (Prodigy Education)
- Oskin & Chen, Efficacy analysis: retrospective QED using CAASPP data (Prodigy Education)
- Prodigy research (Prodigy Education)
- Prodigy (Evidence for ESSA)
- Texas STAAR Grade 3 efficacy analysis, 2023–24 (Prodigy Education, 2025)
- Rohrer, Dedrick, Hartwig & Cheung (2020), A randomized controlled trial of interleaved mathematics practice (What Works Clearinghouse review)
- Van der Kleij, Feskens & Eggen (2015), Effects of feedback in a computer-based learning environment, Review of Educational Research 85(4)
Checked November 2026.
Prodigy Math is a trademark of its owner. AMP is not affiliated with it. Found an error? Write to skylar@corpora.inc.
More comparisons
- AMP vs Reflex: Reflex builds fast recall of math facts. AMP teaches all of math, counting through precalculus, and works beside it.
- AMP vs SplashLearn: SplashLearn turns PreK to grade 5 math into games. AMP explains every miss and runs from counting to precalculus.
- AMP vs Sumdog: Sumdog wraps practice in games and coins. AMP teaches each skill, explains every miss and schedules review.